I mixed up a batch of the citrus fudge and the chocolate peppermint fudge found here this evening. My expectations were low – mostly because the coconut cream that I had bought from Tropical Traditions just hadn’t worked in any recipe I had yet tried. I had bought a case during a promotion a while back, thinking that it would be nice to add to smoothies, etc, and it ended up being too gritty for any application I had in mind. In short, we aren’t fans of coconut cream. But we did have most of a case left, and so I was eager to try out these fudge recipes to see if my expenditure could finally be justified. I also had 8 oz of set honey on hand and so I didn’t have to buy special thick honey just for this (and as a side note, I think regular honey would work just fine with either of these recipes).
I made a half-batch of the citrus recipe first. In comparing the recipes, it looked as if the chocolate recipe was the same basic recipe as the citrus recipe, only halved…and both recipes were supposed to be put in an 8″ x 8″ square pan. I didn’t really see the logic in putting twice as much in one pan as the other, so I just halved the citrus recipe. After tasting the batter, I decided to add extra lemon juice – about twice what was called for. The finished product was nice and lemony. Very refreshing! With the shredded coconut added, it was difficult to detect the grittiness of the coconut cream.
Then I made the chocolate peppermint fudge, using my homemade peppermint extract. I decided not to add the shredded coconut to this one because my son detests coconut and I thought he’d like to try this one. I mixed the recipe as written and then tasted. Not enough minty flavor, and not enough sweetness…so I added more peppermint and about a tablespoon of extra honey. I still wasn’t thrilled with the taste, and the texture was somewhat gritty. I think my peppermint extract is not as strong as a commercial extract, and after adding about 4 tsp I decided that adding any more might impair my judgment. heehee :)
Verdict: Hmm. The recipe was easy to make. That is a plus. Most people probably wouldn’t have the coconut cream on hand so that’s a negative. I liked the citrus fudge enough to make it again, and probably will just make it until I run out of coconut cream. I don’t plan to buy any more to replace it though. The chocolate fudge…well, I felt like it was trying to be something it can’t be – traditional fudge. If dairy was not an option and an uncontrollable urge for chocolate was manifest, *maybe* this would fill the bill. Otherwise, my GAPS hot fudge sauce is far and away a better option in my opinion. I like my chocolate smooth. *shrugs* And I have a feeling that if I can get my hands on some cocoa butter, I could make some crazy good dairy-free fudge without the coconut cream or cocoa.